Enter your search term

Search by title or post keyword

How To Sell Sports Cards the Right Way | Step-by-Step Guide

Are you an avid collector of sports cards such as baseball cards, basketball cards, and football cards?

Are you planning to sell them but you don’t know where to start?

You’re not alone. Many collectors are struggling with selling their collections, particularly sports cards. 

Well, you’re in luck. Selling sports cards is easily done with these steps. You’ll learn all the things you need to consider before selling sports cards and options for the best places to sell. 

Why You Should Consider Selling Sports Cards 

There are several things you should think about why you should sell your sports cards:

  • Potential Profit: Sports cards have emerged as a lucrative market, offering the potential to quickly make money, just like reselling concert tickets. You can turn your collection into a valuable asset, allowing you to reap significant profits.
  • Declutter and Optimize: You can streamline your collection and focus on the cards that truly matter to you.
  • Connect with Fellow Enthusiasts: Trading cards, networking, and interacting with like-minded collectors can help you forge new connections and deepen your hobby love.
  • Explore New Card Acquisitions: If you know how to sell sports cards, it could generate funds to reinvest in new and exciting additions to your collections. 

Problems With Selling Sports Cards

Before diving into selling sports cards, it’s crucial to be aware and understand the potential challenges that may arise. 

Take a moment to consider the following drawbacks that could impact your selling experience:

1. Market Volatility

The sports card market can be highly volatile, with prices fluctuating based on numerous factors such as player performance, demand trends, and market saturations.

A volatile market makes predicting when to sell a challenge. This could result in missed opportunities or lower prices.

2. Authenticity Concerns

Counterfeit sports cards have become a prevalent issue in the market. As a seller, you have to ensure that your cards are authentic to maintain and protect your reputation. 

Subjecting your cards for legitimacy can be time-consuming and requires additional costs. But this will help you ease your mind on your cards’ authenticity.

3. Grading and Evaluation

Determining the condition and grade of sports cards can be a complex process involving detailed examination and adherence to industry grading standards.

If you don’t properly evaluate your cards, you may undervalue or overvalue them, resulting in low potential returns.

4. Saturated Market

The popularity of sports card collecting has surged in recent years, leading to increased competition among sellers. With a saturated market, standing out and attracting potential buyers could be challenging.

Ensure your online presence is strong and offer unique value propositions to attract customers.

What You’ll Need to Sell Sports Cards 

A smiling man selling Sports Cards online at his house

There’re a few essential items and considerations that you’ll need to keep in mind when you sell your sports cards. Here’s a breakdown of what you’ll need:

  • Sports Card Collection: Start by gathering and arranging your sports card collection. Ensure your cards are in good condition and accurately sorted for evaluation and sale.
  • Card Protection Supplies: Use card sleeves, top loaders, or penny sleeves to safeguard your cards from damage and maintain their condition.
  • Research Resources: Stay informed about card values, market trends, and demand. Use online platforms, price guides, and community forums to access reliable research resources and make informed selling decisions.
  • Grading Services: If you have high-value cards, consider using professional grading services to enhance their value and credibility.
  • Online Marketplace Accounts: Create accounts on popular online marketplaces like eBay or dedicated sports card platforms to expand your reach and find potential buyers for your sports cards and other items to sell online. These accounts provide an extensive customer base and convenient selling options.
  • Shipping Supplies: When selling online, you’ll need shipping supplies to pack and send your cards. Bubble mailers, padded envelopes, or cardboard mailers work well. 
  • Photography Equipment: Use a camera or smartphone with a decent camera, adequate lighting, and a clean backdrop to capture appealing and accurate images of your cards.

Where to Sell Sports Cards 

Several popular platforms and marketplaces offer a broad reach and convenient selling options. Here are those options:

1. eBay


eBay is a well-established online marketplace that attracts a large customer base of sports card enthusiasts. It provides a platform for both auction-style and fixed-price listings.

What Makes This Option Great

eBay offers a vast potential audience for your sports cards, increasing the chances of finding interested buyers. This auction format allows for competitive bidding, potentially driving up prices.

Fees/Commissions: On eBay, you can list your first 250 listings of sports cards for free per month. Also, the final value for a sports card is 5% of the total sale plus $0.30 per order.

Payment Methods:

2. COMC (Check Out My Cards)

COMC is an online consignment marketplace specifically designed for selling sports cards online. Sellers send their cards to COMC. They handle the listing, storage, and shipping processes.

What Makes This Option Great

COMC provides a hassle-free selling experience, particularly for sellers with huge card collections. Their professional services handle inventory management, marketing, and fulfillment, saving sellers time and effort.


COMC charges a processing fee at the time of submission, a 5% fixed-price transaction fee, a 3.5% auction fee, and a 10% cash-out fee.

Also, additional fees for PayPal cash-outs under $250, checks sent within/outside the USA, and an incorrect paperwork fee for significant quantity discrepancies may apply.

Payment Method: Sellers on COMC can receive payments through their COMC account balance, which can be used to buy other cards on the platform or request cashouts through Paypal.


3. Facebook Groups and Forums

Facebook groups and online forums dedicated to sports card trading and selling have become popular gathering places for collectors. These communities allow direct interaction and negotiation between buyers and sellers.


Craigslist is a great option for selling sports cards locally. This online classified platform allows you to reach potential buyers in your area who are interested in sports card collecting.

Craigslist lets you list your cards, specify your location, and arrange in-person transactions. Selling bulk lots or huge collections face-to-face provides direct interaction and negotiation

What Makes This Option Great

Selling through Facebook groups and forums can provide a more personal and community-oriented experience. 

Fees/Commissions: Fees and commissions are typically absent or minimal on Facebook groups, Craigslist, and forums since transactions are often conducted privately between individuals.

Payment Methods: Payment methods can vary based on individual agreements, but options such as PayPal, Venmo, or direct bank transfers are commonly used for secure and convenient transactions.

How To Sell Sports Cards: Step-By-Step Instructions 

Now that we’ve covered all considerations on selling sports cards, here are eleven steps on how to sell sport cards.

Step One: Organize and Prepare Your Sports Card Collection

Begin by arranging your sports card collection. Sort them by sport, player, or any other relevant criteria. Remove any damaged or low-value cards from your inventory.

Also, pay special attention to any Tom Brady cards or Mickey Mantle cards you have. These are highly sought-after cards.

Step Two: Research Card Values and Market Trends

Research the current values and market trends of your sports cards. Use online resources, such as card pricing guides or dedicated sports card websites, to determine the market demand and pricing for your sports cards.

Step Three: Determine Selling Platform and Listing Format

Choose a suitable selling platform based on your preferences and target audience. Decide whether you want to list your cards through auctions or fixed-price listings.

Step Four: Capture High-Quality Images

Use a digital camera or smartphone with an exceptional camera to take clear, well-lit photos of each card. Capture the front and back of the cards, showcasing any notable features or condition issues.

Step Five: Write Detailed Descriptions

Write accurate and compelling descriptions for your listings. Include relevant details such as the player’s name, team, year, card manufacturer, and condition. Highlight any unique attributes or special edition cards.

Step Six: Set Competitive Prices and Shipping Terms

Consider factors such as card condition, rarity, and market demand to ensure a fast way to make $1,000 or more. Choose appropriate shipping methods and communicate shipping costs and policies to potential buyers.

Step Seven: List Your Cards for Sale

Upload your high-quality images and write detailed descriptions on the chosen marketplace. Specify the selling price, shipping options, and additional terms or conditions for potential buyers.

Step Eight: Promote Your Listings

Increase the visibility of your listings by promoting them through various channels. Share your listings on social media platforms, sports card forums, and relevant online communities. 

Step Nine: Communicate with Potential Buyers

Respond promptly to inquiries from potential buyers. Provide additional information, address any concerns, and negotiate terms when necessary. Maintain professional and courteous communication throughout the process.

Step Ten: Securely Package and Ship Sold Cards

Carefully package the sold cards using protective materials like top loaders, bubble mailers, or cardboard boxes. Use tracking services and choose reliable shipping carriers to ensure safe delivery to buyers.

Step Eleven: Follow Up and Provide Feedback

After the cards are delivered, follow up with buyers to confirm receipt and request feedback. Also, leave positive feedback for buyers who complete transactions smoothly, fostering a positive selling reputation.

Things to Consider When Selling Sports Cards


When selling sports cards, you need to consider various factors to be successful. Here are some things to consider when selling sports cards:

1. Card Condition and Authentication

The condition of sports cards highly affects their value. Assess the appearance of your cards and consider getting them graded by reputable grading companies.

2. Returns and Refunds

Establish clear policies regarding returns and refunds. Communicate these policies to potential buyers to manage their expectations. 

3. Marketing Your Brand

If you plan to sell sports cards regularly, you can create a noticeable brand name, logo, and social media accounts to establish credibility and attract potential buyers.

4. Legal and Tax Considerations

Understand the legal and tax obligations associated with selling sports cards. Research local regulations regarding online sales, reporting income, and collecting sales tax. 

5. Continued Learning and Adaptation

Stay engaged in the sports card-collecting community and continuously learn about evolving trends, new releases, and modifying buyer preferences. 

Adapting to the market and updating your knowledge can help you stay ahead and make informed selling decisions.

Frequently Asked Questions

How Do I Know if My Sports Cards Are Worth Money?

It’s best to consult with a professional grading service and stay up-to-date on market trends to determine your sports cards’ worth.

You can also research the player’s popularity, the number of prints, age, condition, and unique features such as autographs. 

Is There Still a Market for Sports Cards?

Yes, there is. According to Technavio, the global sports trading card market is projected to grow by USD 6.71 billion at a Compound Annual Growth Rate of 13.36% from 2021 to 2026. 

Similar Tutorials to Check Out

You can check out these similar tutorials for specific sports cards.

Wrapping Up

Selling sports cards may be difficult at first, but following the step-by-step tutorial above provides you with the necessities you needed.

Choosing a profitable selling platform and considering the different aspects discussed in this tutorial are the keys to selling your sports cards.

Remember to stay informed, adapt to market trends, and provide exceptional customer service.

We hope this guide has provided valuable insights and guidance for your selling journey. You can share your thoughts in the comments and share this article with others who might benefit from it.

Leave a Comment

vector graphic showing an illustration of different things to make and sell
  • How to Sell

6 Profitable Things To Make And Sell Online (In 2023)

August 1, 2023
6 min read
vector graphic showing an illustration of feet pics on a website and on an app related to how to sell feet pics
  • How to Sell

How to Sell Feet Pics: Websites, Steps, Tips, & More!

July 6, 2023
9 min read
vector graphic showing an illustration of how to sell replicas legally
  • How to Sell

How to Sell Replicas Legally: Step-By-Step Guide

June 11, 2023
9 min read

Explore More within Gigworker

Other App-Based Gigs
Get to work faster with jobs in the gig worker industry.
post explore

Browse Our Gig Headquarters

The gig economy is booming, and thanks to COVID-19, more people than ever are getting involved. But what is this new sharing economy and how does it work?

Important Gig Economy #Fundamentals to Understand

gigworker logo icon
What is the Gig Economy?

Member’s Area

Unlock access to forums, groups, downloadable content, exclusive courses, and more – just for members.

Create an Account

Side Hustle Ideas

Get inspired with our list of 750+ side hustles. Sort by category, rating, and other custom taxonomies.

Browse Side Hustles

Gig Companies

Browse our complete list of gig economy companies, and the gigs they’re hiring for.

Helpful Content

Read thousands of informative posts, written specifically to help you excel in your favorite gigs.