Enter your search term

Search by title or post keyword

How to Sell Silver Like a Pro in 2023

This post may contain affiliate links - which means we may receive compensation from purchases made through links on this site. Learn more ›

Still haven’t figured out how to sell silver for top dollar?

Many people hesitate to part ways with their silver possessions for fear of getting ripped off. Let me assure you, navigating the silver market isn’t as daunting as you think.

And lucky for you, we have all the information you need if you’re looking to downsize your silver collection and earn extra funds.

We’ll walk you through the tricks of the trade and hook you up with the best platforms for selling your pieces.

So, get ready to turn your silver scrap into cash with this comprehensive guide!

Why You Should Consider Selling Silver

Are you having second thoughts about selling your physical silver? Here are a few reasons that can change your mind:

  • Cash In on Your Investment: Unlock the value of your fine silver collection and turn it into much-needed funds for emergencies and other purposes.
  • Spice Up Your Precious Metal Collection With Some Variety: Make room for new additions by letting go of antique silver items that no longer resonate with you. 
  • Refresh Your Style: Selling unused or outdated silver jewelry allows you to revamp your style and fund for pieces that better reflect your current taste.
  • Declutter and Simplify: Free up space by selling sterling silver flatware and cutlery that have gathered dust in your drawers.

Problems With Selling Silver

Selling silver can be lucrative, but there are some drawbacks to consider. Here are some reasons that can make you think twice before selling:

  • Market Volatility: The value of silver can yo-yo from time to time. Selling during a low point in the market can result in a lower return on investment.
  • Missing Out on Long-Term Investment Potential: Needing emergency funds during unfavorable market conditions isn’t ideal, especially if you expect the value of silver to appreciate. Consider other sources if selling prematurely results in a loss.
  • Transaction Costs: Auction sites for high-value silver pieces involve additional fees and commissions that can eat into your overall profit.
  • Emotional Value: Some silver possessions can have sentimental value, making it hard to let go of them. Weigh the financial gains against your emotional attachment to the silver piece to ensure you have no regrets later.
  • Delay and Risk With Online Transactions: Some online dealers offer a direct price quote, while others do valuations on the physical item after mailing it to them. Shipping your silver poses the risk of loss or theft during transit. 

What You’ll Need to Sell Silver

Here’s everything you need to prepare to ensure a successful sale of your silver item:

  • Physical silver: The silver content of your piece determines its value and desirability, so make sure you have either pure silver or sterling silver. For example, the American Silver Eagle bullion coin contains 99.9% silver.
  • Silver jewelry certificate (if available): The designer or maker provides this official document to prove the originality and authenticity of your items.
  • Assay or Certificate of Authenticity (if available): These documents confirm the purity and authenticity of silver bullion bars or coins.

Where to Sell Silver

A friendly silver seller talking to a customer in an antique store

You’ll find various avenues to sell your silver bullion, silverware, old silver coins, and jewelry. Explore these options and find the one that offers the best price for your silver piece.

1. Online Silver Buyer

Online buyers provide a convenient and direct channel for selling silver. They’ll appraise your items based on their current silver value.

You can sell silver online through one of these platforms:

CompanyWhat They BuyFees/CommissionsPayment Methods
APMEXSilver barsRare coins like the silver eaglesNoneACHDirect depositBank wireBusiness checkTrade for product
CashforSilverUSASterling silverAnything with silver contentNonePayPalCheckBank wires for offers above $30,000
JM BullionSilver bullion, bars, and coinsNoneDebit/credit cardsPayPalGoogle/Apple PayACHBank wirePaper CheckBitcoin
KitcoSilver bullion barSilver, gold, and platinum coins NoneBank wireCredit cardChecke-CheckPayPalOnline bill pay

2. Auction Sites

Auction sites like Sotheby’s give you access to high-end buyers for antique silver items. They can get you the best price for rare and highly collectible pieces if you’re willing to wait.

  • Fees/Commission: Vendor’s commission, marketing expenses, shipping, taxes (if applicable), restoration, and authentication costs
  • Payment Methods: Credit card, wire transfer, or bank deposit

3. Pawn Shops

Your local pawn shops are a viable option if you want a quick sale or need immediate funds.

While they don’t offer the highest price for silver jewelry or coins, they provide a hassle-free transaction and pay on the same day. Plus, they’ll weigh your items in front of you!

  • Fees/Commission: None
  • Payment Methods: Usually cash

4. Antique Stores

Antique collectors understand vintage silver’s historical and artistic values and pay a premium for rare finds.

Selling to antique stores increases your chances of fetching a higher price for your grandma’s silverware.

  • Fees/Commission: None
  • Payment Methods: Usually cash

How to Sell Silver: Step-By-Step Instructions

Here’s a detailed guide to help you sell your silver and maximize your returns:

Step 1: Assess Your Silver

Take inventory of your silver assets and evaluate their quality, purity, weight, or rarity.

Antique silver from the UK and Ireland contains the most structured hallmarks for purity or fineness, including:

  • Assayer’s mark: British silver marks include the lion passant, leopard’s head, or seated figure of Brittania. Irish silver bears a crowned harp.
  • City mark: Silver hallmarked outside London has a unique emblem of the town where the assay office that stamped the silver can be found. Examples include Birmingham’s ship anchor and Edinburgh’s three-towered castle.
  • Date letter: This mark indicates the period spanning two years when the silver was hallmarked. The letter’s font and the shape of the shield encapsulating the letter vary between different assay offices.
  • Maker’s or sponsor’s mark: Vintage silver bears the master silversmith’s punch symbol of the workshop where it came from. Meanwhile, the sponsor’s mark indicates the retailer who subcontracted the manufacture of silver.

You can also check your items for these markings to know their silver content:

  • 999: This mark represents the purest form, with 99.9% silver.
  • 950: This number indicates Brittania silver, which contains 95% silver.
  • 925: This value signifies sterling silver, an alloy of 92.5% silver and 7.5% copper or other metal.
  • 900: This alloy is 90% silver and may include the words “Coin” or “Standard.”

US silver has no standard date marking system, so companies like Tiffany and Gorham adopted their distinct date imprints.

Close-up of silver jewelers with black background

Step 2: Track the Silver Spot Price

Stay in the loop about the latest market trends for silver so you have a ballpark figure in mind.

That way, you’ll have a realistic expectation of your items’ worth and ensure you’re getting a fair deal.

You can check out the spot price of silver using live online price charts like Business Markets Insider.

You can also download a mobile app that monitors gold and silver price movements. It provides charts for studying trends and sends notifications when the price hits your desired level.

Step 3: Research Potential Buyers

You can navigate different channels that buy silver pieces, such as:

  • Online platforms
  • Pawn shops
  • Auction houses
  • Local coin dealers
  • Jewelry stores
  • Antique collectors

Read reviews and seek recommendations to ensure you sell to a trustworthy and reliable buyer.

Lastly, consider factors like convenience, speed of transaction, and payment options to find the best method that fits your needs.

Step 4: Get Appraisals and Quotes

Don’t settle for the first offer that comes your way. Instead, consider obtaining multiple valuations from different sources to compare prices.

You can visit local stores or contact online buyers offering free appraisals. Provide information about your silver’s history, weight, purity, and other distinguishing characteristics.

If you need to mail your silver piece so you can get it appraised, package your item securely.

Step 5: Prepare Your Silver for Sale

Make sure to clean and polish your silver to enhance its appearance. Take high-quality photographs of your pieces to showcase their beauty and attract potential buyers.

If you have the original authenticity document or sales receipt, gather them to provide further verification.

Step 6: Negotiate and Finalize the Sale

Get ready to negotiate the price when the buyer shows interest. Consider their offer and counter with a reasonable figure based on fair market value.

Once you reach an agreement, finalize the sale. For online transactions, arrange shipping if you still have your item.

Use appropriate packaging to avoid damage during transit. Or, you can insure the shipment for added protection.

Arrange for secure payment after receiving the final offer. Leave feedback for the buyer, if applicable. 

Things to Consider When Selling Silver

A close-up of a sliver buyer calculating the value of the weighted silver

Getting into the silver trade has unique considerations. Below are other factors to keep in mind before selling your precious silver:

1. Silver Price Fluctuations

Silver is more susceptible to price swings than gold, despite being the cheaper precious metal. The market price can experience significant movement due to new policies, economic conditions, and investor sentiment.

2. Quality

Buyers and collectors seek out silver items that exhibit superior craftsmanship and are in excellent condition. Intricately designed pieces also command higher prices.

3. Industrial Demand

Experts predict the price to skyrocket because of its increasing use in electronics, solar applications, medical devices, and electric cars.

Understanding the future demand for silver can provide insights into its value and potential growth.

Keep an eye on emerging trends that can affect the spot price of silver. You’ll want to hold on to your pieces to capitalize on the projected price increase in the future.

4. Selling Strategy

Develop a clear selling strategy based on your goals and circumstances. Decide whether you want to sell your silver items individually or as a collection.

For instance, rare coins appeal to collectors, and you’re better off selling them separately for some serious cash. Lower-quality coins will derive value from their silver content, making them easier to sell as a group.

On the other hand, matching silverware is more desirable as a collection. If you have the complete set, it can drive up the price even more.

5. Safety

Safeguard your silver by documenting each piece and taking photographs for reference. Detailed records can be helpful in disputes or other issues.

Also, be vigilant when handling large sums of cash, especially when leaving a pawn shop or jewelry store. Ask the buyer for safer payment options like Venmo, PayPal, or Apple Pay. 

Frequently Asked Questions

How Much Will I Get if I Sell My Silver?

Aside from weight, purity, and any additional premium on collectible items, the price of silver largely depends on the market price.

For example, if you have a 2-ounce pure silver coin and the spot price is $20/oz, you can make around $34–$38. Sterling silver, such as silver flatware and jewelry, sells for less because of the costs involved in refining it. 

Is Silver Easy to Sell?

Yes! Silver is among the most popular precious metals to trade, so it’s easy to sell.

There are numerous channels available for selling silver, including both physical stores and online marketplaces.
Choose a reputable buyer to get a fair price for your silver and ensure a smooth transaction.

Similar Tutorials to Check Out

Check out these tutorials if you have other bling aside from silver that you want to sell:

  • How to Sell Gold: Be a savvy gold seller using our insider tips and tricks. You’ll learn to navigate the precious metal market and find the best buyers for your gold coins and jewelry.
  • How to Sell Diamonds: Sparkling diamonds deserve a brilliant selling approach. Master the 4Cs (cut, color, clarity, and carat) and discover the best strategy to maximize your returns when selling diamonds.
  • How to Sell a Wedding Ring: Find your wedding ring a new home and a fresh start. This tutorial will guide you through market demand, appraisals, and the best platforms for selling a wedding ring.

Wrapping Up

With this guide, you now have the best tips and insights on how to sell silver. Know the spot price of silver and take the time to shop around for the best offers.

So, do you think you can turn a profit with your antique silver? We’d love to hear your thoughts on the silver trade in the comments section below.

And feel free to share this guide with a friend who wants to make a quick buck from silver!

Pro tip: Take things to the next level by selling silver as a side hustle

Leave a Comment

vector graphic showing an illustration of different things to make and sell
  • How to Sell

6 Profitable Things To Make And Sell Online (In 2023)

August 1, 2023
6 min read
vector graphic showing an illustration of feet pics on a website and on an app related to how to sell feet pics
  • How to Sell

How to Sell Feet Pics: Websites, Steps, Tips, & More!

July 6, 2023
9 min read
vector graphic showing an illustration of how to sell replicas legally
  • How to Sell

How to Sell Replicas Legally: Step-By-Step Guide

June 11, 2023
9 min read

Explore More within Gigworker

Other App-Based Gigs
Get to work faster with jobs in the gig worker industry.
post explore

Browse Our Gig Headquarters

The gig economy is booming, and thanks to COVID-19, more people than ever are getting involved. But what is this new sharing economy and how does it work?

Important Gig Economy #Fundamentals to Understand

gigworker logo icon
What is the Gig Economy?

Side Hustle Ideas

Get inspired with our list of 750+ side hustles. Sort by category, rating, and other custom taxonomies.

Browse Side Hustles

Gig Companies

Browse our complete list of gig economy companies, and the gigs they’re hiring for.

Browse Gig Companies

Helpful Content

Read thousands of informative posts, written specifically to help you excel in your favorite gigs.

VIP Membership

Unlock access to VIP-only benefits like content, downloadable, and resources – all ad-free.